Dropbox: Why argyle doesn't make you a tool

Earlier this week, Dropbox debuted a redesign of its logo and visual system. Out is the blue box icon on a field of white. In is set of 5 (sometimes blue) diamonds arranged to be reminiscent of a box on a field of a contrasting color which may or may not be white. I realize that some may expect me to come out and say that I don’t like the design, or that when I look at it I want to go out and buy a pair of argyle socks. That is not what I am going to write about today. Instead, I want to use Dropbox’s new socks identity to highlight the problem of navel-gazing marketing.

Dropbox went from a box to five diamonds arranged to be reminiscent of a box

I once had a marketing professor who used to push the idea that as a marketer, your job is to be a tool. One whose purpose in life was to investigate, understand and find ways to connect with your company’s target customers. However, over the years it has become clear to me that far too many of our peers in the world of brand, marketing and business have misinterpreted the idea and taken it as an order to be foolish. Because rather than focus on developing strategies and tactics, brand platforms and campaigns, products and services that speak to their consumers, time and time again we see brands that have chosen the easy route of marketing to themselves.

TIME AND TIME AGAIN WE SEE BRANDS THAT HAVE CHOSEN THE EASY ROUTE of MARKETing TO THEMSELVES.

If you haven't used it before, Dropbox is a service that allows users – whether consumers or companies –  to store files of all sorts on the web. You can access these files from anywhere, using a browser or a downloadable app, you can sync files across your PC and smartphone, share files and folders with colleagues, and enjoy access to your stuff wherever you are. It’s a lot like Apple’s iCloud, Google’s Drive, and Box’s…um…Box. See the problem? Online file storage is a commodity, and as the cost of storage continues to fall, the ability for companies like Google and Apple to offer up fully-integrated alternatives to Dropbox has put the company in a tough spot. It means that the Dropbox brand needs to help the company stand out and seem like more than its commoditized competition.

DROPBOX IS “AN OPEN PLATFORM, AND A PLACE FOR CREATION.” SERIOUSLY, THAT’S WHAT IT SAYS.

With an IPO on the horizon later in the year, and competitors taking big bites out of Dropbox's core business, it’s clear that the organization needs to build up some momentum. So, what’s the solution? Apparently, a key piece is to make the case that Dropbox isn’t (just) a storage company. You see, Dropbox is “an open platform, and a place for creation.” Seriously, that’s what it says. Dropbox’s design page also talks about how the underlying idea for the brand is “Extraordinary things happen when diverse minds come together.”  The team talks about how people want to do creative work that matters, not busy work.  You know what I hear?

Dropbox is a platform for creative people (like us) to be creative (like we want to be) instead of dealing with details of modern work (because that's not fun).

Call me naïve, but that strikes me less as a broad value proposition and more a reflection of the attitudes of the people who developed the brand. Which brings me back to the call for marketers to be tools for their companies. As it stands, the shift to a younger, hipster-cum-millennial audience is something that we see over and again.

source: homescorner.com; mark sebastian via flickr

We don't do this because it is a smart marketing move, not because it creates an aspirational pull that marketers can leverage to grow their business, but because we, as marketers, have become too lazy, too insular, too attached to the echo chambers of our social networks that we believe to understand our audience is as simple as checking our feed. The truth? It’s not. Getting to know people unlike yourself and how to connect with them in a real and meaningful way is the true test of a marketer. Anything else is just phoning...er...tweeting it in.

GETTING TO KNOW PEOPLE UNLIKE YOURSELF AND HOW TO CONNECT WITH THEM IN A REAL AND MEANINGFUL WAY IS THE TRUE TEST OF A MARKETER. ANYTHING ELSE IS JUST PHONING...er...TWEETING IT IN.

So, while I applaud Dropbox’s team for developing a striking and creative visual system, the story behind it and the strategic choices implied suggest a desire to do something splashy rather than something that drives the business. All of which means that the Dropbox brand isn’t working as a tool for the business. It’s just being a tool.